Mod-Rewrite 或 PHP 路由器?

2022-01-02 00:00:00 routing php

我正在讨论使用以下两个选项之一路由我的请求:

I am debating routing my requests with one of the two options:

选项 1:使用 Mod-Rewrite 和漏斗编写的简单捕获路由 $_GET 路由到 index.php 以加载...

Option 1: simple capture route with Mod-Rewrite and funnel written $_GET route to index.php for loading...

#default routing
RewriteCond %{REQUEST_FILENAME} !-f
RewriteCond %{REQUEST_FILENAME} !-d
RewriteRule    ^blog/([0-9]+)?$    index.php?rt=blog&params=$1    [L,QSA]
// ..more custom routes, and then a default route
RewriteRule    ^([A-Za-z]+)/([A-Za-z]+)/(.*)?$    index.php?rt=$1/$2&params=$3    [L,QSA]

选项2:简单地将请求路由到Front Controller，并创建一个PHP路由类来处理路由...

Option 2: simply route requests to Front Controller, and create a PHP routing class to handle the routing...

#default routing
RewriteCond %{REQUEST_FILENAME} !-f
RewriteCond %{REQUEST_FILENAME} !-d
RewriteRule ^(.*)$ index.php?rt=$1 [L,QSA]

/* --- on front controller, process $_GET['rt'] --- */

归根结底，哪个会运行得更快、更容易保护、更容易维护?

at the end of the day, which will run faster, be easier to secure, and be easier to maintain?

还有其他想法吗?

注意:我没有运行已知的框架.我正在构建自己的 MVC 模式来学习它.

NOTE: I am not running a known framework. I am building my own MVC pattern to learn it.

推荐答案

通常在 MVC 框架中，这类事情通常最好由前端控制器(名为 index.php 或类似)处理.然后您使用 mod_rewrite 从所有 URL 中隐藏 index.php，以便您的用户看到漂亮的干净路径.

Usually in MVC frameworks, this sort of thing is usually best handled by a front controller (named index.php or the like). You use mod_rewrite to then hide index.php from all of the URLs so your users see nice clean paths.

在 PHP 中处理比在 Apache 的重写指令中更容易处理.PHP 更灵活，更容易编写/理解.现在我想起来了，我不确定我是否曾经见过将 mod_rewrite 用作任何 Web 框架的唯一路由引擎.

It's also way easier to handle in PHP than in Apache's rewrite directives. PHP is much more flexible and easier to write/understand. I'm not sure I've ever seen mod_rewrite used as the sole routing engine for any web framework out there, now that I think of it.

你的第二段代码是你重写指令的方法.

Your second snip of code is the way to go for your rewrite directives.

相关文章